
Nykole Kinh
Saskatoon StarPhoenix
Saskatchewan drivers are facing a nearly eight per cent hike on their car insurance bills, but there are fears that it won’t be enough to offset the rising costs of crashes.
The province’s sole provider of vehicle coverage dipped into reserves to cover additional costs of claims over the past four years, drawing down a $1-billion rainy day fund to $633 million.
A report warns that it could diminish further to $171 million in two years, raising concerns the fund could be headed for insolvency.
“We are running out of time to reverse course on providing ourselves a way out that does not require taxpayer intervention,” said Derek Lothian, the head of the Insurance Brokers Association of Saskatchewan.
Lothian worries there may be less than 18 months left to restructure the auto fund before it’s too late.
Saskatchewan drivers have enjoyed the same premiums over the past 12 years — while other Canadians faced hikes of as much as 22 per cent over the last year.
That’s come at a steep cost, as the provincial public auto insurer faces financial problems that appear to trace back to Covid.
Saskatchewan drivers are required to purchase basic vehicle coverage from provincial insurer Saskatchewan Government Insurance. British Columbia and Manitoba also have provincially regulated insurance programs.
Saskatchewan’s auto fund is meant to operate on a self-sustaining basis to collect enough premiums to pay out insurance claims. It draws from its rainy day fund — formally called the rate stabilization reserve — to buffer periods of volatility when claims spike.
As more advanced features roll out across cars, the more auto repairs cost. That trend doesn’t look like it will ease up anytime soon.
Saskatchewan rejected the suggestion that its compulsory public auto insurer could face insolvency in the coming years, despite a government-appointed panel outlining that risk.
A seven-person panel is responsible for reviewing rate changes for Saskatchewan’s Crown corporations. It reported that the $630-million buffer to bankroll Saskatchewan’s auto insurance could drop to $171 million by March 2028.
That situation, if it happened, would put Saskatchewan Government Insurance at serious risk of going bust.
Jeremy Harrison, the provincial minister responsible for the insurance corporation, said the auto fund is under pressure but that it’s righting the ship.
“There’s no path in front of us that’s going to lead to insolvency. The government will never allow the auto fund to become insolvent,” Harrison said to reporters.
After 12 years without any rise to car insurance, Saskatchewan drivers are about to be hit by a 7.6 per cent hike, split between this year and next year.
That’s still below what many other Canadians have paid. In just three and a half years, from the start of 2023 to June 2026, premiums went up by an average of 43 per cent, according to a recent report from insurance brokerage management firm Applied Systems Canada.
Alberta has seen the steepest increases over the last year with a nearly 23 per cent jump, the report says.
Still, a number of Canadian auto insurers have logged unprofitable quarters in the last several years.
According to Statistics Canada, the first three months of 2024 were the worst for underwriters as insurance expenses outweighed revenue by three per cent nationally. That’s before factoring in other operating expenses.
Insurers’ capacity to cover personal vehicles is thinning, based on the national data. But Saskatchewan had it the worst across provinces.
Saskatchewan paid out 11 per cent more in claims than it collected in insurance premiums in 2024, based on the most recent data from Statistics Canada.
Alberta’s private insurance companies had a similar issue as they paid an average of eight per cent above premiums that same year.
But the other two compulsory government insurance providers were in a better situation.
The Insurance Corporation of British Columbia had just a bit of money left over after covering auto claims.
Meanwhile, Manitoba Provincial Insurance’s payout ratio suggested it was in profit-making territory.
Saskatchewan’s premium adjustment still might not be enough to offset the costs of car repairs.
It follows a four-year trend of the Crown corporation drawing from the reserve, nearly halving the balance over that time.
Drew Kendel, executive vice-president and chief financial officer with Saskatchewan Government Insurance, was asked if the insurer’s own projections are in line with an independent forecast suggesting the financial cushion could fall to $171 million without new measures.
Kendel said an ongoing tariff war impacting the cost of car parts makes it difficult to pin down exactly where that reserve will be.
“As of today, we would expect it to be slightly higher than that,” said Kendel. “But you know, I’m not at liberty to put the exact number out there today.”
The rate review panel commissioned a technical report from Cathcart Advisors Inc. and Risk Consulting Services Inc. The independent financial consulting firms said the fund needs “a multi-year plan to achieve rate sufficiency and stave off the risk of insolvency.”
The Saskatchewan government and executives with the public insurer have not explained when they expect to restore the reserves.
For every $1 in auto premiums collected by the auto fund in 2024-2025, it incurred $1.21 in claims costs, according to the technical report.
“The cost of claims is now exceeding, reliably, the premiums that are generated and earned. I think that is obviously the core problem that we have to address,” Lothian said.
Not long ago, the auto fund’s financial cushion was almost double what it is today.
The nest egg grew during Covid lockdowns when people stayed at home more often, resulting in fewer drivers on the road and fewer collisions.
Saskatchewan Government Insurance issued a total of $285 million in rebate cheques to insured drivers to get the reserve back down to its internal target.
But the auto insurer didn’t have the hindsight it has today, says Lothian.
The insurer didn’t anticipate that inflation on car parts and repairs would outpace average inflation, making it more expensive in the following years, Lothian explains.
“It’s really difficult — if we’re being honest with ourselves and with the conditions of the day — that that was the wrong thing to do,” says Lothian.
“Would we do it again, looking backwards? Absolutely not. But it’s hard to argue that it was the wrong decision with the information that they had.”

