Roughriders Mailbag: Confidence check? Playoff format? Emilus update?

Heywood Yu/Regina Leader-Post Saskatchewan Roughriders receiver Johnny Johnson III (88) runs the football as Calgary Stampeders defensive back Bailey Devine-Scott (21) defends during the second half of CFL football action at Mosaic Stadium in Regina on Friday, October 2, 2026.

Taylor Shire

Regina Leader-Post

Welcome to another edition of the Roughriders Mailbag where we answer questions readers have about the Saskatchewan Roughriders.

Following a third straight loss, the Roughriders head into the final three games of the season with several issues that need to be addressed.

With a home-and-home with the Montreal Alouettes next up on the schedule before wrapping the season against the Edmonton Elks, the Roughriders need to quickly find those answers if they want any hope of defending their Grey Cup title.

In today’s reader mailbag, we answer questions about the current state of the team, while also addressing a topic for next year.

If you’d like to submit a question for the next Roughriders Mailbag, email your inquiry to: SaskatchewanRoughriders@Postmedia.com

This team doesn’t look like the defending champs anymore. Will they have any confidence going into the playoffs? From Doug

At this point, we don’t even know if they’ll make the playoffs. They should, but there’s an outside chance they won’t

After a third-straight loss, the Riders (8-7) now occupy the third spot in the West ahead of Calgary (8-8) since Saskatchewan has a game in hand. However, the Stampeders can quickly move ahead as they have the season series tiebreaker between the two teams.

With Montreal twice and Edmonton, the Riders have the toughest schedule, however there’s a chance both of those teams could be resting starters with their respective divisions secured.

If the final three weeks goes as expected, Edmonton will finish first and B.C. will finish second, leaving Calgary, Saskatchewan and Winnipeg fighting for the final two spots.

At this point, the Blue Bombers (7-8), who also have the season series over the Riders, don’t appear to be much of a threat with Dru Brown at quarterback but could make a move with three divisional games as they play Calgary, Edmonton and B.C. However, those teams are also playing for seeding.

There’s plenty to be decided in the final two weeks, so I’ll say this: if the Riders win two of their final three, they will likely finish third and head to B.C. for the West semifinal. If the Riders win one of their final three, they will likely finish fourth and head to Toronto for the East semifinal. And if the Riders lose all three, they’ll be out of the playoffs altogether. We’re about to find out if that’s true.

The Riders do not have the quality American receivers they had last year. A year ago, they had Meyers and Robustelli along with KeeSean Johnson. This year, nobody has stepped up. Who is our American deep threat who stretches the defence of the other team? From Gary

Replacing Dohnte Meyers, who is now playing a big role with the Cincinnati Bengals, was no small task. And losing Joe Robustelli, who is now in Edmonton, turned out to be a bigger loss than it should have been.

While KeeSean Johnson, Samuel Emilus and Kian Schaffer-Baker make up an incredibly potent three-headed monster, keeping them all on the field at the same time has been troublesome.

Last year, Johnson and Meyers eclipsed the 1,000-yard mark while the next closest receiver, Emilus, had 588 yards. Meyers averaged 16.2 yards per catch while Robustelli averaged 14.3 in the 12 games he played.

This year, Canadian rookie Daniel Wiebe is tops among receivers with an average of 17.1 yards per catch. The only problem is that he only has 17 catches as he’s been used sparingly while being in and out of the lineup.

American rookie Jaylen Johnson earned a starting job out of camp but didn’t pan out as the team had hoped while fellow American Johnny Johnson III (12.5 yards per catch) has been a serviceable receiver since entering the lineup.

However, he hasn’t been able to take the top off a defence like Meyers did last season.

So, to answer your question, they don’t have an American deep threat who can stretch the defence. But if they can get KeeSean, Emilus and Schaffer-Baker all on the field at the same time, it gives quarterback Trevor Harris, a methodically quick passer, the opportunity to put together consistently long drives, while taking the occasional deep shot — likely to Schaffer-Baker, who is now healthy and averaging 15 yards per catch.

Realistically though, an American deep threat receiver is the least of this team’s concerns.

Sam Emilus; I don’t see any mention of when he might return. Can you fill me in on his status? From Ken

It appears Emilus is getting close to returning to the lineup, and we might get more clarity on Thursday, when the Roughriders return to practice ahead of Monday’s game in Montreal. He’s been doing some individual work on the sidelines during practice but hasn’t rejoined the team since his leg injury in Week 12.

However, even if he returns to practice, it might make sense to hold him out another week and have him play Oct. 17 against those same Alouettes. That gives him two weeks to get ready for a playoff game — if the Riders can get that far.

There’s also of course good news coming defensively, as cornerback Tevaughn Campbell should return this week, which will give the secondary the boost it needs.

Getting Emilus and Campbell back in the lineup could give this team the spark they need.

Next year’s playoff structure needs to be changed! What can be done to fix it? From Phil

While there are still three weeks left this season to determine who makes the playoffs and who doesn’t, we will know a lot earlier next year which teams are in.

That’s because the CFL is changing the playoff format so that eight of nine teams will make the postseason. It frankly makes the regular season almost meaningless, while adding some potential revenue for more teams in the form of an extra home playoff game.

In my opinion, similar to yours, it needs to be changed.

A best-of-three West and East final, with the top two teams in each division facing off against each other, would be entertaining. Each team would get a home game with the third game, if necessary, back in the home of the No. 1 seed. If there’s a sweep, then the winning team gets a bye week before the Grey Cup. However, that best-of-three format is not going to happen.

Instead, one change I would recommend is to have the regular season mean something by factoring in points in the standings when it comes to playoff games.

So, if the first-place team finishes two points ahead of the second-place team in the standings, the first-place team would start with a 2-0 lead in their divisional showdown. The same goes for the No. 6 seed vs. The No. 7 seed play-in game and the No. 5 vs. No. 8 play-in game. You need to reward teams that finish higher in the regular season with more than just home-field advantage.

After the first round of the playoffs, you can scrap the point differential and let the postseason roll on with the new format.

It’s a change that would make every single regular season game meaningful, with literally two points on the line each week.

I’d appreciate your take on what I perceive to be a flaw with the team, namely, lack of a mobile quarterback. Whether it’s the Lions with Rourke, the Argos with Kelly, even the Elks with Fajardo, or Als with Alexander, all these teams have QBs that, when necessary, can run with the ball to avoid getting sacks in order to find an open receiver or make a gain on the ground. As good as Harris is, he doesn’t have the same evasiveness when it is needed in order to save a play. Yes, he has a quick release, but there is no added option to run and then pass, which these other QBs have. From Ken

Looking at the top five teams in the league — Montreal, Edmonton, B.C., Toronto and Calgary — you’re right: all five have mobile quarterbacks. It hasn’t always been that way, but it’s becoming more common among top teams.

Having a quarterback who can effectively throw and run is certainly an extra weapon in a team’s offence. I don’t necessarily think the Roughriders would be better off with a quarterback who can run and pass, because I believe Trevor Harris is among the CFL’s best at his position with his arm alone.

However, more important than basic running ability is elusiveness. The ability to get out of the pocket and evade pressure before making a throw down field is a skill that only a few of the elite quarterbacks mentioned above have. Tucking the ball and running towards a first down is a skill that almost all quarterbacks have.

There is risk, as mobile quarterbacks generally take more hits than the ones who don’t run as often, but it is certainly something to consider when the Roughriders are forced to figure out who takes over for Harris when he eventually decides to retire.

That could be next year. It could be in a few years.

Jack Coan is next in line, and while he can run, he’s more of a pocket-passing quarterback. We know what Tommy Stevens offers, but it doesn’t appear the Roughriders want to let him throw the ball. Rookie Brayden Schager would certainly be the best option for this team when it comes to dual-threat quarterbacks as he showed promise in the pre-season.

Unless the Roughriders target a quarterback in free agency, there’s going to be a massive question mark at the position whenever Harris does hang them up. Certainly, they would love to find a proven, dual-threat quarterback — like any team would — and I’m sure it’s something they’ll consider in the off-season.

-Advertisement-